I’ve been hear­ing a lot about Chevrolet’s new elec­tric car, the Volt. It is sup­posed to be America’s answer to Toy­ota in the green car exhi­bi­tion. On Chevrolet’s elec­tric car site, they proudly pro­claim, “It’s unlike any pre­vi­ous EV (elec­tric vehi­cle), thanks to its inno­v­a­tive recharge­able elec­tric drive sys­tem and range-extending power source.” This “range-extending power source” can be gaso­line, E85, or biodiesel. Which makes it a hybrid, no? Like the Prius parked in my garage. The only dif­fer­ence seems to be that the Volt does not use the gaso­line engine unless you run out of elec­tric­ity, mak­ing electric-only trips pos­si­ble for short dis­tances. Of course, I can do that today with a mod­ded Prius, or one I buy in Japan. The Volt is a plug-in hybrid con­cept vehi­cle with lot of mar­ket­ing hype. And not much else.

Tagged with:
 

6 Responses to Is the Chevy Volt just another hybrid?

  1. Ken says:

    The major dif­fer­ence is that the engine only charges the bat­ter­ies in my under­stand­ing. There­fore, it can be highly spe­cial­ized to that one task.

  2. David says:

    The Volt is sim­ply not a Hybrid. Period.

    The Volt dri­ves using elec­tric­ity stored in bat­ter­ies 100% of the time. The wheels are pow­ered by elec­tric motors 100% of the time and never by a drive shaft.

    Chevy also opted to add an elec­tri­cal gen­er­a­tor to the car which can pro­duce elec­tric­ity in the event the bat­ter­ies run dry due to a long road trip or the owner sim­ply for­got to plug in the car the night before.

    The on-board elec­tri­cal gen­er­a­tor can be gas power, E85, pure ethanol, bio diesel, or even fuel cell as soon as the tech­nol­ogy per­mits this to be a rea­son­able choice.

    This car is WAY ahead of it’s time and even fur­ther ahead of any other car company’s “green” efforts.

  3. Danny says:

    David, we are agreed that the Volt con­cept is a plug-in elec­tric car that can burn fuel only when absolutely necessary.

    GM has taken a mod­ern, tech­ni­cally advanced elec­tric car con­cept and added a gas engine (pow­er­ing a gen­er­a­tor) to it. I do not dis­pute that it is a fan­tas­tic piece of engi­neer­ing. I do not dis­pute that it will get excel­lent gas mileage by rarely using its “range-extending power source.”

    But this does not mean that GM has rev­o­lu­tion­ized the elec­tric car. Electric-drive-only, plug-in options have been avail­able for other cars for years, even on gas-married mod­els like the Prius (con­verted by Cal­Cars in 2004). There’s no inno­va­tion in that con­cept. The E-Flex dri­ve­train may be inno­v­a­tive, and some of the other engi­neer­ing pro­posed by the Volt may be inno­v­a­tive, but they did not just re-invent the elec­tric car.

    See: Cal­Cars Plug-In Hybrids page
    and: Google’s ReChargeIT project

    The ear­li­est date Chevy has pro­posed for pro­duc­tion is 2010. Which means this car does not yet exist. We have no idea how it will per­form, what the electric-only range will be, how much it will cost to buy, etc. For now, it is a tremen­dous exer­cise in the mar­ket­ing of lab­o­ra­tory ideas.

  4. mark says:

    It is sup­posed to be America’s answer to Toy­ota in the green car exhibition.

    Well I think that prob­a­bly tells you all you need to know at this point about the Volt. That’s like lute­fisk being Norway’s answer to sashimi.

  5. James says:

    Posted to http://www.edmunds.com is the following

    The specs for triple-digit fuel economy:

    The Volt fea­tures a front-mounted elec­tric motor that gen­er­ates 120 kilo­watts of power (160 horse­power) and 236 pound-feet of torque. Lithium-ion bat­ter­ies are housed beneath the Volt’s floor. Also onboard is a 53-kilowatt elec­tric gen­er­a­tor. The tur­bocharged, 1.0-liter three-cylinder gaso­line engine also fits up front, while the 12-gallon fuel tank is in the rear.

    The Volt will drive about 40 miles on pure elec­tric power. Vehi­cle Line Direc­tor Tony Posawatz (whose name rhymes with “kilo­watts”), says GM arbi­trar­ily picked this dis­tance because Depart­ment of Trans­porta­tion stud­ies show that half of U.S. house­holds travel less than 30 miles per day, while 78 per­cent of com­muters travel no more than 40 miles per day to work.

    Most Volt dri­vers would use lit­tle or no gaso­line,” Posawatz notes.”

    ref­er­ence:
    http://www.edmunds.com/insideline/do/Features/articleId=119088

    COMMENT: I have some expe­ri­ence dri­ving bat­tery elec­tric con­ver­sions in New Eng­land. They need a fuel-fired source of heat for wind­shield defrost­ing and cabin heat, so I sus­pect GM engi­neers will con­sider either run­ning the gen­er­a­tor in cold weather to pro­vide that heat source for the safety and com­fort of the motorist. They could wire in resis­tance heaters for those pur­poses plus seat warm­ers, but that will reduce the battery-only drive range by 10 or more miles dur­ing cold weather.

  6. Danny says:

    As noted above, it remains to be seen just what the Volt can do when it turns up as a pro­duc­tion vehi­cle. Until then, it is a break­through in mar­ket­ing terms only.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Set your Twitter account name in your settings to use the TwitterBar Section.